legal client

legal client

Home - Uncategorized - Bork-Peril Justice

Bork-Peril Justice

Posted on February 9, 2019 in Uncategorized

On June 6, 2007, Robert H. Bork caused to be filed a lawsuit in the Federal Court for the Southern District of New York, wherein he is the named Plaintiff, and the Yale Club of New York City is the named Defendant.

Mr. Bork’s cause of action arises out of an incident which occurred on June 6, 2006, on which date Mr. Bork was visiting the Yale Club, a private club, in New York City, to deliver a speech at a luncheon sponsored by the New Criterion Magazine. It is perhaps interesting to note that Mr. Bork, though not a Yale alum, was a professor at the Yale School of Law during the Sixties and Seventies. He is currently a Professor of Law at the Ave Maria Law School located in Ann Arbor, Michigan. It does not appear that he was on medical leave during the 2006-2007 academic year.

Mr. Bork’s complaint was not verified, but was signed by his attorneys on his behalf. Your correspondent is unfamiliar with New York legal procedure. It is unknown whether there is a one year statute of limitations on tort actions in New York, and the suit was started on the last possible day it could successfully been brought, or if the filing on the one year anniversary of Mr. Bork’s injury was merely coincidental.

While attempting to ascend the dais on the date in question, Mr. Bork lost his balance, and fell backwards, hitting his left leg on the subject dais and hitting his head on an inconveniently placed heat register. While other, lesser, non-originalist, non-textualist men may have been deterred from a further assault on the lofty height, Mr. Bork, being a trouper, was made of sterner stuff. Though he may have been bloodied, he was unbowed. He raised himself up from the shambles of his fallen self, ascended that self-same dais, and delivered his oration like a good ‘un. It is unknown whether the head injury affected the form or content of the speech. I suspect that, after his talk, and after thunderous applause, Mr. Bork descended the dais, unaided, shook the hands of many well-wishers, and left the premises. One assumes, but admittedly does not know, that Mr. Bork, as a Virginia resident, employed in Michigan, was paid some small stipend for his comments.

The members of the Yale Club may well have been distressed, if not confused to read the subsequent complaint served on the organization by Mr. Bork’s attorneys. The complaint alleges that the Yale club failed to provide a safe dais or stairs or a handrail between the dais and the floor. Also, the dais was at an unreasonable height from the floor.

Mr. Bork’s complaint contains two counts, one alleging negligence and one alleging gross negligence. The allegations of fact in both counts are exactly the same in both counts except the words “wantonly, willfully and recklessly” are substituted in Count Two for the word “negligently” in Count One.

Mr. Bork alleges a leg injury (apparently the injury to his head from the heat register resolved), causing a large hematoma, which later burst, requiring surgery. Excruciating pain resulted, which prevented him from working his “typical” schedule after the injury. He also endured months of “relative inactivity” due to his injuries, and was “largely immobile” for some months.

Medical bills were incurred, and some lost income alleged, though, as indicated, he gave his speech that day, and was not listed as “on medical leave” on the Ave Maria website.

What does the complaint indicate that Mr. Bork, the accident victim, deserves in order to make him whole for this injury, caused by the negligence and willful, wanton, and reckless conduct of the Yale Club:

1. $1,000,000, and

2. Punitive damages, and

3. Pre-and post-judgment costs, interest and attorney fees.

For those who may not know Mr. Bork, he has served as Solicitor General of the United States, acting Attorney General, and Federal Court of Appeals Judge. In 1987, he was nominated for the US Supreme Court by President Reagan. His nomination was vigorously opposed by many groups, and the Senate eventually rejected his confirmation. The word “Bork” has now become a verb and as of 2002 has appeared in the Oxford English Dictionary. The word is defined: “To destroy a judicial nominee through a concerted attack on his character, background and philosophy.” During the confirmation process, opponents went so far as to obtain Mr. Bork’s video rental records. It is some interest to note that one video rented by Mr. Bork was the Marx Brothers’ “A Day at the Races”.

So we see that even highly educated, intelligent persons with long pedigrees of public service like Mr. Bork can become victims of negligent and reckless actions by organizations and corporations.

While it appears that Mr. Bork has much in common with many other persons injured apparently through no fault of their own, we should not separate Robert Bork the victim from Robert Bork the legal scholar and philosopher, and former judge, quite yet. For while this case may be the first occasion where Mr. Bork has been a part of the legal system in the role of injured plaintiff, he has previously expressed some definite opinions on the subject.

Mr. Bork has long been an advocate of “tort reform” measures to restrict the rights of injured persons. As recently as 2002, in an article he authored in the Harvard Journal of Law and Public Policy, Mr. Bork that Congress, by legislation, displace state tort law. He admitted, however, that the framers of our Constitution did not grant Congress such power. Mr. Bork wrote:

“State tort law today is different in kind from the state tort law known to the generation of the Framers. The present tort system poses dangers to interstate commerce not unlike those faced under the Articles of Confederation. Even if Congress would not, in 1789, have had the power to displace state tort law, the nature of the problem has changed so dramatically as to bring the problem within the scope of the power granted to Congress. Accordingly, proposals, such as placing limits or caps on punitive damages, or eliminating joint or strict liability, which may once have been clearly understood as beyond Congress’s power, may now be constitutionally appropriate.”

Such a federal tort system would, Mr. Bork believes, combat the problem of frivolous claims and excessive punitive damage awards that apparently plague state courts.

Mr. Bork has long been an advocate of judicial restraint. He has criticized judges who “legislate from the bench.” Reinterpreting the US Constitution to grant Congress powers admittedly not included by the Constitution’s authors sounds like a liberal dose of judicial activism to me.

Admittedly, I know very little about the facts of Mr. Bork’s accident. If the Yale Club did not provide a means of ascending a dais and if it was a very high step and if there was no support provided, I can see how a case of negligence could be proven. No argument from me that the claim itself is frivolous. And, if Mr. Bork can prove his case, and if he incurred medical expenses, and wage loss and pain and suffering, he is entitled to reasonable compensation from the responsible parties. That seems to make common sense. But what makes this case especially interesting, is the nature of the claims a person of
Mr. Bork’s philosophy makes against the parties he holds responsible and the relief to which he claims he is entitled. It is also equally fascinating to consider what relief Mr. Bork get if his accident occurred under similar circumstances at the Detroit Athletic Club, Detroit, Michigan, the state where Mr. Bork is employed as a Professor of Law. And, coincidentally, a state where much of the indigenous judiciary has made Mr. Bork’s legal philosophy (or what they thought it was), the law of this state.

First, let’s take a closer look at Mr. Bork’s New York complaint. Quite honestly, if there is negligence here, it is because someone at the event didn’t think a step or railing to the dais was needed. Or forgot to even think whether one was necessary. Or accidentally removed on that was already there. Simple carelessness. Well, that is not quite good enough for Mr. Bork, the advocate of restraint, and the opponent of the frivolous claim. He alleges that the actions of the Yale Club were not merely negligent or careless, but willful, wanton and reckless. Maybe I misunderstood the facts. Maybe a member of the Yale Club threw him off the dais.

Anyhow, the actions of the Yale Club were so shocking the Mr. Bork does not merely want reasonable compensation ($1,000,000), but Mr. Bork wants the Yale Club to pay punitive damages, which of course he will be happy to keep for himself.

The reader might say that if the law in New York is so screwed up so as to allow people to collect such damages, why should Mr. Bork, merely because he doesn’t personally believe in such remedies, be precluded from obtaining all allows.

I would agree. It takes a man of strong character to let his personal beliefs restrain him from glomming onto all the bucks he can.

Except for this. Mr. Bork asks for punitive damages. New York law does not allow them. Mr. Bork asks for pre-judgment interest. New York law does not allow it. Mr. Bork asks for attorney fees. New York law does not allow them. Mr. Bork asks for $1,000,000 compensatory damages in his complaint. A federal complaint need only claim damages of $75,000 to invoke the jurisdiction of the court.

Now if these are the kind of remedies Mr. Bork wants included in the national tort law legislation he advocates, he might find that he has a lot more support among plaintiff attorneys than he thought.

Second, let’s move the location of Mr. Bork’s accident to the great state of Michigan, where Professor Bork helps develop the skills of future members of our state Bar.

In Michigan, the jury Mr. Bork demanded in his complaint would never hear his case. Mr. Bork would not get compensatory damages, much less punitive damages, even if the owners of the club admitted negligence. Mr. Bork could have fallen and killed himself due to the admitted negligence of any and all possible defendants, and Mr. Bork’s estate would be entitled to nothing other than possibly the bill for cleaning his blood off the dais.

Like Mr. Bork, many members of the Michigan Supreme Court are members of the Federalist Society, long-time advocates of “tort reform”. Mr. Bork’s judicial philosophy is called “Originalism.” The judicial philosophy of the Michigan Supreme Court majority is called “Textualism.” They are merely different euphemisms to label what is the worst kind of judicial activism as judicial restraint.

Well, cases decided by Mr. Bork’s adherents on the Michigan Supreme Court would make short work of Mr. Bork’s complaint. The height of a step is something Mr. Bork could see, so it was up to him to make sure he ascended it without injuring himself. The club has no duty to provide a step or railing or warning or anything else. After the fall, Mr. Bork ascended the dais without falling again, which is elegant proof that he should have done it without falling the first time.
If Mr. Bork was to argue that there was no other way to get onto the dais other than climbing an excessively high step, he would be no further ahead. Michigan cases would inform him, as his case was dismissed, that he was not required to ascend the dais at all. He could have spoken at floor level. He could have refused to speak at all, or he could have had the event cancelled and rescheduled for another day when there was a step or railing to the dais. If he had simply followed one of those three available alternate courses of action, he would not have fallen. If he hurt himself he has only himself to blame.

If Mr. Bork did not like the result of his Michigan case, he could appeal its dismissal. And some time down the road after an Appeals Court upheld the dismissal, Professor Bork might find himself using his own case to teach his Ave Maria law class the advantages of “tort reform.”

Robert Bork is a fine teacher. He teaches us a great many things by his actions in this case. First, the principles of tort reform apply to others, not to me. Secondly, frivolous suits are those brought by everyone–else. Thirdly, legal philosophy be damned–show me the money!!

May there always be men and women who will protect the common citizen from those who think them worthy of no consideration.

From the Originalists and the Textualists, Good Lord, deliver us. And, as they might say at the end of class at Ave Maria Law School—Amen.

sex dictionarysex diseasessex education filmsex facts for teenagerssex health tipssex medicine for malesex positions during pregnancysex power medicinesex relationshipsVibrators and Adult Toyssex pills for womensex relationshipsonline dating businessonline dating catfishonline dating eliteAdult Superstoresexuality counselingsex facts and tipssex power medicinesex relationshipssex related wordssex pills for womensex relationshipsFree Online CasinoOnline Casino Gamesthe best online casino gamesWinning Strategy GamesBest Gaming ExperiencePlay Online Casino GamesOnline CasinogamblingSlots gamblingThe Best Online CasinoPlay Online Casino GamesPlay Online CasinoPlay Online PokiesReal Money SlotsOnline Slots and CasinoPlay Online SlotsReal Money CasinosPlay Slot Machines OnlineReal CasinoJackpot Party Casino SlotsReal Casino Slots Appssex dictionarysex diseasessex education filmsex facts for teenagerssex health tipssex positions during pregnancysex power medicinesex relationshipssex related wordsVibrators and Adult Toyssex pills for womenonline dating businessonline dating catfishonline dating eliteAdult Superstoresexuality counselingsex facts and tipsonline dating servicesex good for healthsex positions during pregnancysex power medicineHome and Patio Decor CenterHome RemediesThe Best Smart Home Security SystemsHome Design IdeasHome Decorating IdeasBest Home BuildersHome Building Online CoursesHome Builder MarketingTop Living Room FlooringBest Logistics SoftwareBest Application ComparisonShipping Software SolutionsLogistics Management SoftwareLogistics Software SystemsSoftware DevelopersSystems Software DevelopersSoftware Developer EducationMost Popular Software ApplicationsTechnology ApplicationsPhone System SoftwareInformation TechnologySpy Phone Technology downloadSmartphone Spy Phone TechnologySoftware DevelopersSystems Software DevelopersSoftware EngineerSoftware Developer EducationAndroid Software ApplicationsMost Popular Software ApplicationsCell Phone Monitoring SoftwareSoftware Technology Technology ApplicationsBest Application ComparisonShipping Software SolutionsWedding IdeasVirgin on Wedding Nightfind the meaning of weddingWedding WebsitesVirgin on Wedding NightWedding Planningwedding planning tipsbusiness planOnline Services for Businessespublic relationsSmall Business TrendsTips Small BusinessBest Application ComparisonSoftware DevelopersSoftware Developer EducationAndroid Software ApplicationsMost Popular Software Applicationscheap ray ban sunglassesTravel Insurance InformationBackpacker AdviceKitchen DesignPatio Cover Installationstw girl asiachat tubeLandscape ConstructionLandscape DesignCheap HotelsTravel TipsTravel GuidesTravel InformationCheap Flight and Hotel Packages?Travel InsuranceCheap Hotels and FlightsBest RestaurantsVegetarian RestaurantsHotels And ResortsBest Hotel RestaurantTravel InformationTrip Travel InsuranceCompare Cheap HolidayTravel InsuranceFind Cheap Hotel DiscountsCheap Hotels and FlightsCheap HotelsTravel TipsTravel GuidesTravel InsuranceFind Cheap Hotel DiscountsAddiction CausesCauses of Alcohol AddictionCauses of drug addictionDrug Abuse InformationSubstance Abuse ProgramsChoosing a Addiction Rehab ProgramDrug Rehab Treatment InformationNew Drugs OnlinePersonal productSell Products OnlineMarketing ProductProduct Research AnalystProduct Research FacilitatorThe Food Products General ProductsBeauty Products Businessbeauty salon productstroke sonyNatural Health MagazineBedroom Designsinterior design ideas bedroomPremature ejaculationHealth Tonics HerbsNatural Health MagazineElectrical System Vehicle The Shop Bulk OnlinePremature ejaculationwww.777chat.infowww.777good.infowww.twshowkiss.infowww.twtalk080.infowww.twavtalk.infowww.twshowlove.infowww.twavsexy.infowww.twavroom.infowww.twavmovie.infowww.twsexy888.infowww.twsexyadult.infowww.adult506.infoThe Legal Adviserwww.twavshow.infowww.twavnice.infowww.asia222.infolawyerLegal advisorThe Lawyer Portalgood tubeDrug Abuse InformationTravel GuidesHotel and Travellegal colorlegal lesslegal markslegal wishlegal flowerlegal dollarlegal nightlegal soniclegal flaglegal widgetlegal clientlegal overlegal blasterlegal formulalegal ganglegal splashlegal messengerlegal memberlegal dishlegal requestlegal urbanlegal sustainlegal water frontlegal sparklelegal surrealfood lessfood pipefood sendfood chartsfood wishfood collectorfood econofood cupidfood fiestafood grabberfood gorillafood rulefood musclefood last minutefood matchefood kayakfood arrowfood hotrodautomotive sendautomotive marksautomotive lionautomotive requestautomotive collectionsautomotive otherautomotive excelautomotive treasureautomotive railautomotive streamingautomotive rallyautomotive crawlerautomotive hardautomotive catcherautomotive charmautomotive appealautomotive cupidhealth positivehealth lasthealth varietyhealth offlinehealth normalhealth jokerhealth millionshealth omegahealth glamourhealth guerrillahealth electrahealth urbanhealth gloryhealth precisionhealth flavorhealth intergrityhealth collectionshealth collectorhealth calculatorhealth otherhealth excelhealth sugarhealth metrichealth hardhealth opediahealth famehealth classyhealth drawhealth slidehealth vectorhealth collecthealth sweethealth legacyhome a bundanthome backhome battlehome britehome browserhome buddieshome cachehome calculatorhome catchhome catcher home charmhome chartehome chartshome chasehome circushome collectorhome companionhome dollarhome dollarshome stickhome letterhome flaghome widgethome clientFood ProductsFinancial ProductsGeneral Auctionsoperating systemsproduct activationProduct KeysProduct Key FinderHeating SystemsHome AutomationHome Automation SystemBuilding SuppliesBuilding DesignerBuilding ConsultantsBathroom AccessoriesAppliance RepairsEquipment HireExtensions & AdditionsFloor Coating ProductsFurniture RemovalGarden MaintenanceGarden DesignerInterior DesignerInterior DecoratingKitchen DesignLandscape ConstructionLandscape DesignProject ManagementLandscaping & GardeningPatio Cover InstallationsTile SuppliersHome Access ControlHome Alarm SystemsHome Intercom SystemsHome Security Card AccessPlumbing InstallationHome Entertainment SystemHome Improvement MistakesHome Improvement LeadsHome Improvement TipsHome Improvement GrantsHome Improvement StoresHome Improvement ProjectsGreen Home ImprovementsMarketing strategyMarketing ConceptAffiliate marketingSmart Affiliate Marketing StrategiesBest Affiliate Marketing NetworksWomen Lawyersbusiness shufflebusiness precisionbusiness flavorbusiness verdebusiness intergritybusiness gratisbusiness epicbusiness anchorbusiness clearancebusiness eastsidebusiness corporationbusiness featurebusiness cellarbusiness plumbusiness divinebusiness prontobusiness carnivalbusiness east baybusiness dodgebusiness prestigebusiness razorbusiness atlanticbusiness huskybusiness remarkablebusiness fighterbusiness quantumbusiness courierbusiness constructbusiness sparklebusiness rainforestbusiness falconbusiness lightningbusiness blodbusiness downtownbusiness curiousbusinessafterbusinesss alvagebusiness overnightbusiness captivebusiness amazingbusiness abundantbusiness designingbusiness blenderbusiness imaginebusiness justbusiness surrealshoppinghuskyshoppingnationsshoppingremarkableshoppingfightershoppingquantumshoppingpeachshoppingpresidentshoppingsparkleshoppingrainforestshoppinglightningshoppingdowntownshoppingravenshoppingsalvageshoppingpriorityshoppingmysticalshoppingpermanenttravellightningtravellowpricetravelmeasuretravelmillionstravelmysticaltravelnationstravelnaturetravelnobeltravelnormaltravelnorthamericantravelofflinetravelomegatravelonedaytraveloutertravelpickuptravelplatinumtravelplumtravelprecisiontravelprestigetravelprioritytravelprontotravelquantumtravelrainforesttravelraventravelremarkabletravelrhinotravelsalvagetravelscribetravelshuffletravelsleuthtravelsnapshottravelsouthbeachtravelsparkletravelsunflowertraveltopsecrettravelurbantravelyankeelegalagendalegalcupcakelegaldodgelegaleastbaylegalescrowlegalgeckolegalglorylegalguerillalegallimitedlegalmysticalInterior Designer WebInterior Designer WebInterior Designer WebInterior Designer WebInterior Designer WebInterior Designer WebInterior Designer WebInterior Designer WebInterior Designer WebInterior Designer WebPersonal productSell Products OnlineMarketing ProductProduct Research AnalystProduct Research FacilitatorThe Food Products General ProductsBeauty Products Businessbeauty product skin carebeauty salon productonline productMarketing Products to Advertiseonline shop originals ProductNew ProductsProducts Definitiongigi hadidsuper modelproduct marketingPersonal ProductsBooking ApartmentsDefinition of ApartmentSecure ApartmentDesign Apartmentsgirl room decorationfree information ApartmentAsia ApartmentGirl Makeup ProductsGirl ClothingGirl Cookieschat girlchat adultchannel asiaGirl Dress CosplayJapanese School Girl Dressapartment for girlApartment BrokersApartment Nice home theater systems floor plans blenders heaters switch fixtures lighting furniture electric fences glass kitchen carbon filters kitchen sink home improvement bed kitchen cabinets aluminum water filter houseplants personal injury health insurance bad credit loans fast cash advances cash advance loans insurance loans auto insurance loans for bad credit payday loan loans with bad credit injury lawyer personal injury lawyer personal loans online payday loan fast cash loans malpractice insurance brokerage firm injury lawyers Consulting immigration law business law accident attorney home builders car insurance consolidation loans fast cash online loan application cash advance companies payday advance instant payday loans application form apply now cash loan make money free money life insurance affordable health insurance mortgage structured settlement European Vehicle Market Vehicle Systems Electrical System Vehicle business autocar Online Drivers Car Education Online Drivers vehicle technologies electrical Auto Parts and Service technology supports autocar driver education requirements Online Programs Driver Education Auto Information Auto and parts Automobile Repair Shop Auto Parts Suppliers Auto Repair Shop Auto Body Parts Online Auto Body Parts apartments real estate luxury condos Commercial Property For Sale Commercial Real Estate Commercial property Apartments for rent apartment finder service Find Apartments for Rent Apartment Luxury Homes Real Estate Developments Mortgage Rates Best Mortgage Rates Free Online Dating Tips on Free Online Dating Psychology of Your Online Dating Partner Free Online Dating Services Free Online Dating Website Dating Site for Women Free Dating Site And Free Online Dating Making online dating sex dictionary sex diseases sex education film sex facts for teenagers sex health tips sex medicine for male sex good for health sex positions during pregnancy sex power medicine sex relationships sex related words Vibrators and Adult Toys sex pills for women sex relationships sexuality photos sexuality scale sexuality in america sexuality and society sexuality and space sexuality counseling sex facts and tips sexuality confusion online dating tips online dating scams online dating service online dating business online dating catfish online dating elite online dating guide Adult Superstore International Travel Forum World Travel and Tourism travel in the world Business Travel Insurance travel trailer rental vintage travel trailers cheap places to travel cheap travel packages how to travel for free travel destinations travel canada to us travel reviews travel system agent online travel job as travel agent job for travel agency one travel com triple a travel best travel backpack travel agent salary loves travel center Travel and Leisure Adventure Travel Airline Travel the best online casino online casino games Best Gaming Experience Play Online Casino Games Online Casino gambling best casino gambling Slots gambling Online Casino Reviews The Best Online Casino Play Online Casino Games Play Online Casino Play Online Pokies Real Money Slots Online Slots and Casino Play Online Slots Real Money Casinos